Identity Politics Themes Exceptionally Well Written in Playwright Marisa Carr’s “Reconciliation” / An Indigenous Voices Presentation by Intermedia Arts and Pangea World Theater

By John Townsend November 18, 2014

Categories: Arts & Culture, Featured - Home Page, Our Scene

Photo by Bruce Silcox.

Photo by Bruce Silcox.

A major pitfall of plays written about identity is that they fall into sloganeering and simplistic generalizations about the oppressed v. the oppressor. The paradox within that is that serious complex issues of bigotry and oppression are not credibly rendered. However, Marisa Carr’s new drama, Reconciliation, delves into the complexity with relish so that even if one doesn’t tend to be sympathetic to her concerns, they will definitely be confronted.

Carr seems to have a terrible awareness of how our current era of unchecked surveillance and endless war could eventually un-do the US constitution. In this sense, it is actually a patriotic work that stretches far beyond only racial concerns. Pangea World Theater director Dipankar Mukherjee has balanced the piece’s stunning intelligence with deep feeling, though transitions between the scenes could move more deftly.

Photo by Bruce Silcox.

Photo by Bruce Silcox.

Reconciliation is a dystopian play set a century in the future about Native Americans who essentially are incarcerated in internment camps in Minnesota – incarceration simply because of their race and because of an America whose military-prison-industrial complex has expanded far beyond what it is today. The inmates are not only victims of impoverished living conditions but polluted drinking water there is so toxic that it has been a major contributing factor to early deaths.

Playwright Carr, who also portrays the protagonist role at Intermedia Arts, splendidly inhabits the role of a native woman reminsicent of Antigone who refuses to reconcile with the injustices and degradations enacted upon her self, her family, and her people in the 21st and 22nd century. Though the historic genocide of Native Americans is referred to, it’s what’s happen in the recent past of the play’s setting that is the general focus. Reconciliaton also shines a light on the problems and issues of reconciliation efforts of recent years that we’ve seen in Bosnia, South Africa, and other countries. Though the notion is noble, it can also become dishonest.

Photo by Bruce Silcox.

Photo by Bruce Silcox.

Moreover, Carr doesn’t let her own people off the hook. Jake Waid gives engaging performances as both a Native American prosecutor who sees many of his own people as “enemy combatants” and also as a freedom fighter. Sharon Marie Day gives touching performances as both a reasonable court judge and as “grandmother’. The production is nicely enhanced by Mike Wangen’s lighting and Peter Morrow’s sound design. The ramshackle set design by Charlie Her Many Horses artfully reflects an internment camp interior.

Through Nov. 23
Intermedia Arts, 2822 Lyndale Av. S., Mpls.
(612) 871-4444

One Response to Identity Politics Themes Exceptionally Well Written in Playwright Marisa Carr’s “Reconciliation” / An Indigenous Voices Presentation by Intermedia Arts and Pangea World Theater

  1. Chuck F says:

    Seen this show, the concept is great, set is amazing, Day and Wald made good choices about the work so kudos to the director. Sound and Lighting are on par with the professionals who created them.

    However, and I really feel bad for pointing this out,

    Carr is just not good at acting and the performance, if you can call it that, was flatter than her monotone speaking voice. It seemed to me that she didn’t do any character development as an actor should. During points when real moments of emotion should show through, Carr was in robot mode. I almost laughed out loud at her inability to act like she was crying. Of course, John doesn’t even try to review her performance, because, well I have no Idea why, maybe because the content is really exceptional. Her chemistry with the other actors doesn’t exist. I don’t think she made eye contact with the other actors at all. During long stretches, she was just stared at the walls when she spoke to them.

    In my opinion, I don’t think this emerging good playwright should have cast herself in the lead of an otherwise great show. Brava Pangea but please, start vetting these writers who also want to try acting, because this is an example of the emperor having no clothes.

Links to this post
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!